We’re nearing the end of The Way Home’s third season, so the twists and reveals are coming fast and furiously now. And if you’re feeling like you need a Carrie Mathison-style board (and possibly a Tylenol) after this Friday’s antepenultimate episode, we don’t blame you.

Surprisingly, the hour did not follow-up on last week’s cliffhanger, in which Casey Goodwin jumped into the pond, implying that they’re a time-traveler from the future. But we did get plenty of other shocking pond action, beginning with a confused teenage Colton landing in 1814. When he stumbled onto the Landry farm with no idea of where/when he was — this must be his first time doing the time-hop — Elijah welcomed the water-logged stranger in a nice parallel to how adult Colton would one day welcome in a time-traveling Elliot.

Before Colton prepared to leave for home, he urged Jacob to plant potatoes and rye instead of his usual crop. He couldn’t explain how he knew that the wheat and corn would die, but pleaded for Jacob to trust him.

“Why do I feel we’ve met before?” Jacob asked curiously, to which Colton replied, “Because we’re cut from the same cloth.” Oh, Colton, if you only knew then how true that statement is!