Justin Hartley has been winning over the hearts of television watchers for decades now. While fans of the actor all have their favorite roles — mine happens to be his work as Kevin Pearson in NBC’s Thursday night hit series This Is Us — Hartley also has one moment in his career that he feels most proud of, and it perhaps shockingly has nothing to do with his iconic Green Arrow suit he wore on the DC super-drama Smallville.

Hartley shared a list of details with Us Weekly that even his biggest fans don’t know about him. In the middle of those factoids, the Tracker star shared what he feels is the proudest moment of his career, and it just so happens to tie directly to the CBS drama that returned to the 2025 TV schedule in February.

The action drama series is adapted for the screen from the 2019 novel The Never Game, and follows Colter Shaw (Hartley), an experienced survivalist who helps law enforcement and private citizens locate missing people and solve crimes. The first season was met with strong viewership, scoring the broadcast drama an early Season 2 renewal, and as of February 2025, it was picked up for a third season.

Hartley pulls double duty on the show, playing the lead role and also serving as one of the top executive producers alongside showrunner Ken Olin. It marks the first time the star has produced television since getting his acting start in the early aughts.