These lost flavors will bring back childhood memories

Pop-Tarts are a staple of American breakfast. With how popular they are, there have been plenty of flavors to touch the shelves over the years, only to be discontinued due to a lack of popularity or a desire to switch things up. In this article, we go over some of the most beloved discontinued Pop-Tarts flavors, from tame options like Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and Grape to unique combinations, like Guava Mango.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Peach Cobbler

Red Velvet

Apple-Currant

Strawberry Cheese Danish

Banana Crème Pie

Wild Watermelon

The Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough was beloved among Pop Tart enthusiasts for its sweet, balanced flavor. The cookie dough reportedly mixed well with the pastry, making for a unique flavor that highlighted the best aspects of both of them. Since it disappeared in 2022, fans have desperately tried to get the Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pop Tart back through petitions and social media comments. [1]

Pop-Tarts confirmed the flavor’s shelving in a comment on X on July 8, 2022, saying “Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pop-Tarts have been discontinued, but don’t worry: other flavors can fill that void.”

This popular flavor was great for making ice cream sandwiches. Pop-Tarts suggested cutting them in half, scooping ice cream onto them, and sprinkling them with chocolate morsels before freezing them for 2 hours.[2]