If you’re on the hunt for a lip color that won’t budge or move throughout the day, the best lip stains can do just that and more. Take it from me, who’s tried and tested over two dozen lip stains in my nearly 7-year beauty career, but I have to say, it took me a while to find the right ones. I've tried formulas that were either barely-there, or so staining that it took days to remove traces of the color (flashbacks to vigorously rubbing with makeup wipes still haunt me to this day). But, after much lip stain trial and tribulation, I can finally say that I’ve found a slew of options that pass the test: they’re hydrating, not overly staining, and don’t budge if you eat or drink. Our top pick is Fenty Beauty’s Poutsicle Hydrating Lip Stain because it lasts all day, holds up effortlessly (we’re talking through multiple meals) and has a very comfortable barely-there wear.

Ahead, the makeup artist-approved lip stains that we’ve tried and tested. Take it from me: these will give you the long-lasting, bold color you’re looking for, sans the mess.

According to the makeup artists we spoke to, lip stains aren’t bad for your lips but they do have long-lasting power. While lipsticks, glosses, and lip balm products, can last a few minutes to a couple of hours, lip stains temporarily dye the skin, and can last up to a whopping 8-12 hours. If you think that sounds a little too permanent, don’t worry, you can easily remove them with a makeup remover. Plus, they’ll save you the headache of having to reapply your lipstick or carry it around for touch-ups.